Jordan Tomooka
Active Reading Notes:
Montaigne Essays
Book I:
That Men by Various Ways Arrive at the Same
End:
·
Follows
how many people try to avoid their fate
·
nothing
can stop a motivated confronter from causing harm
·
those
showing courage are usually allowed to live
·
People
with power for revenge can have us laying at their mercy
·
that
pride of powerful people can make them irritated with the courageous rising up
against their power
·
States
ego leads to the powerful trying to break the courage of the courageous
·
Courage
comes from meeting fear of death
Of Sorrow
·
sadness
as hurtful idle cowardly and mean
·
the
strongest emotions cannot always be expressed
·
The
strongest love cannot be expressed
·
Those
who express great love do not feel great love
That Our Affections Carry Themselves Beyond
Us
·
hat
people spend too much time thinking of the future and need to live in the
moment
·
this is
a view nature encourages
·
Rousseau
says that fear desire and hope make us thing of the future always
·
you
have to do your own work to know yourself
If you know yourself you will never
take another’s work as yours
·
One
will improve oneself this way
·
Though
we do our own when alive we cannot talk to others when we are dead and are left
with whatever legacy we created
·
Montaigne
feels a good legacy is needed to be happy in death
·
when he
dies it us up to the living to take care of his body
That the Soul Expends its Passions Upon
False Objects, Where the True are Wanting
·
when a
soul is agitated it needs an object to act upon or else it will turn on itself
·
we like
little dogs and monkeys because there is a part of us that needs to love
·
Animals
attack the thing that attack it
·
Humans
always need something to blame
·
some
blame god
Whether The Governor of a Place Besieged
Ought Himself to Go Out To Parley
·
To buy
time a Roman king offered peace to an enemy and used the lull to fortify and
attack
·
Senate
thought it cowardly and disapproved
Notes that all that matters is that the
enemy was defeated
·
Honor
of war goes to the winner no matter the way they won
·
Because
of surprise attacks the leader should not go to negotiate unless very protected
·
If on
the verge of certain defeat it is better to compromise
That
the Hour of Parley Dangerous
·
war is
changing and faith cannot be secured until peace is signed and even then one
must be wary
·
Montaigne
agrees with Chrysippus that one needs to use all force available but not
“Cheat”
·
Alexander
refused to use darkness as cover to not “Steal”the victory
That
the Intention is Judge of Our Actions
·
“Death
discharges us of all our obligations”
·
The enemy
of Henry VII ran and was found by Don Phillip who agreed to give Henry his
enemy if no harm came to him
·
Henry
instructed his son that when Henry dies he is to kill his enemy
·
Montaigne
feels Henrys death didn’t cancel the agreement
·
A man
gave advice on a situation out of his control
·
When
finding out he was wrong had himself put to death to not go back on his word
·
Montaigne
feels this was unnecessary because the situation was out of the man’s control
·
Makes
note of people who leave people things in their will because of feeling guilty
of wrongdoing to said person
·
Montaigne
sees this as meaningless since you make no sacrifice because you are dead and
don’t need those things anyway
·
Expresses
distaste at people who reveal grudges at death extending their hatred to the
living instead of taking it with them in death
Of
Idleness
·
the
Mind needs a study to restrain from wandering uselessly
·
an idle
mind makes foolishness
States that a soul without a goal loses itself
·
Montaigne
retires to his house to avoid distraction and allow his mind to wander
·
Commits
his wanderings to writing to guilt himself out of wandering
Of
Liars
·
Montaigne
notes his bad memory
·
foolish
people are said to have no memory
·
When
Montaigne complains of his literal memory people think him calling himself
foolish
·
strong
memory goes with weak judgment
·
his
friends questioning his friendship when he forgets things thinking he doesn’t
care
·
Feels
that by having a weakness in memory he has avoided other weaknesses
·
Also
that by this weakness his other faculties are stronger
·
the
memory has more information than intellect
·
Comments
that people with strong memories go into so much detail they ruin stories
States weak memory helps forget injuries
·
Untruths
are things we perceive as true
·
Lies
are things we say as true but we know are false
·
Two
types of liars
Of
Quick or Slow Speech
·
some
people are never surprised with speech and speak quickly and others
need to
think hard about what they are going to say and talk slowly
·
States
a preacher needs to be a slow one because he was so much time to prepare
·
A
lawyer needs to be fast because they have unexpected questions and objections
·
that
wit is thinking promptly and suddenly
Judgment is taking time to thing
·
some
people can only perform without preparing only with a care free attitude
·
Worrying
too much about success can cause someone to hinder themselves
·
Montaigne
always performs worse when prepared
Of
Prognostications
·
fortune
tellers have been losing credibility since before Jesus
·
there
are many people who still use stars and body shapes and dreams to tell
f or tunes
·
Shows
how people always want to know the future
·
Tells
of an ally to the French so terrified by good fortune predicted for French
switched side with regret
·
Montaigne
would rather use a dice than idle and vain dreams
·
Those
who try to predict and eventually get one right and say it is proof of fortune
telling
·
Montaigne
sees as lucky and liars
·
he’d be
more convinced that predictions were always wrong
Of
Constancy
·
Constancy
means we should do all we can to avoid harm but face those we can’t avoid
bravely
·
Don’t
condemn action used to defend one’s self
·
countries
using retreat in battle
·
Though
it is bad for a soldier to leave his post it is inevitable through acts of fear
·
a
fortune teller would see the man’s apprehension when Montaigne sees it as
impossible to predict
·
Says
non philosophers will abandon reason and change behavior while the philosopher
will not
The
Ceremony of the Interview of Princes
·
Feels
it would be better to offend someone once than himself always
·
everywhere
has different customs
·
Montaigne
is very educated in the customs of his own country but doesn’t always follow
them
·
Sees
some people as rude for being over civil
·
Though
he doesn’t follow the rules he feels it is important to know them because
people set examples for each other that others take notice of
That
Men Are Justly Punished For Being Obstinate In the Defense of a Fort That is
Not in Reason to be Defended
·
bravery
has limits if limits ignored leads to stubbornness foolishness and arrogance
·
Punish
by death those who defend places that losing is inevitable
·
Strength
of a fort is measure by the force attacking it
·
There
is danger that someone would see themselves as too high up and attacks any
opposition
Of
the Punishment of Cowardice
·
Charondas
made cowards spend three days in public dressed in women’s clothing to “ Awaken
their courage”
·
Julius
sentencing those who fled the battlefield to death when in a similar occasion
only punished by lowering rank
·
Montaigne
sees shameful punishment as harsh and cold creating enemies out of the
punished
·
Extreme
cowardice can only be taken as malice
A
Proceeding of Some Ambassadors
·
men
prefer to talk of other men’s duties
·
Caesar
speaks about bridges and such but is more quite on war duties and military
conduct
·
Montaigne
says this will never improve a man
·
People
need to talk of their own capabilities
·
Pay
attention to people for what they do
·
People
naturally want liberty and power
·
Obedience
should be cherished
Complete obedience has limited commands
·
Ambassadors
have to use their discretion in managing affairs
That
We are to Avoid Pleasures, Even at the Expense of Life
·
It is
time to die when there is more evil than good in the world and to preserve
their torture goes against the very rules of nature
·
St.
Hilary murdered his only daughter because she was hypnotized by the riches of a
suitor
That
Fortune is Oftentimes Observed to Act by the Rules of Reason
·
A
painter was frustrated with his painting and threw a sponge at it hoping to
deface it but instead made it better and it became his style
·
Describes
fortune as almost human like in the way it affects others even noting that
fortune judges more than humans do outlining good and bad karma
Of
One Defect In Our Government
·
the
world is not generally corrupted
·
his
father employed a man to keep a journal for him and reflects that he wants to
imitate his father
Of
the Custom of Wearing Clothes
·
People
are clothed to protect themselves from nature but we have destroyed it making
them and other commodities
If we needed clothes to survive we would have been
created with thicker skin
·
Plato’s
advice not to wear anything on the head or feet for health
·
Calls
the King Mexico superfluous for changing his clothes four times a day and never
using the same dish twice
Of Cato
the Younger
·
the age
he lives in is so unintelligent that virtue is defective
·
Plutarch
says that Cato only died because he feared Caesar and that Cato was actually a
pattern that nature chose to show human virtue and constancy
·
it’s
easier to write poetry than understand it
That
We Laugh and Cry for the Same Thing
·
Children
laugh and cry at the same things because of their innocence The soul darts our
its passions imperceptibly
Of
Solitude
·
we
should either imitate the vicious or hate them however both are dangerous It is
not enough to physically remove oneself from the conditions that have taken the
soul but one needs to sequester and come again to himself
·
Though
we are naturally selfish, the death of a loved one is feared more than the
death of ourselves
That
the Relish of Good and Evil Depends in a Great Measure Upon the Opinion We Have
of Them
·
People
are tormented on their opinion of things rather than the actual things
·
Death
pain and Poverty are considered our principal enemies
·
While
Plato believes that pain and please work together to form the soul, Montaigne states
that they separate it
Not
to Communicate a Man’s Honour
·
Honor
is rooted deeply within us and no one can discharge themselves from it
·
No matter
the argument people have little power to resist honor because it is part of us
·
Personal
honor extricates morals values and feelings
Of
the Inequality Amongst Us
·
People
are judged on their clothing and other possessions rather than their bodies
which are more useful to them
·
Hints
that physically strong and capable people must have a strong and capable soul
noting that physically strong body parts make a person worthy not their
possessions
·
Compares
kings public and private behavior to that of actors in and out of the theatre
·
Attaining
desirable things makes us happier than having them
·
Serving
external conveniences make the mind and body disorderly
·
is
easier to follow than to lead
·
satisfaction
of only answering to yourself and having one path to take
Of
Sumptuary Laws
·
hypocrisy
in regulating vain and idle expenses in meat and clothes by the very
people
whose environment is gold
·
Believes
in laws diverting people from pleasures attracting men in honor and ambition to
duty and obedience
Of
Sleep
·
kings
who fall asleep and don’t wake up or wake up and have their lives taken
·
physicians
don’t know whether sleep is necessary alluding to men who died from lack of
sleep and another who hasn’t slept in months
Of
Names
·
saying
that it is important to have a good name and comments on the convenience
of
having an easy to pronounce name that is easy to remember
·
Socrates
saying its worth a fathers time to find good names for his children
·
Praises
Jacques Amyot for being able to pronounce Latin names properly with no French
twist
Of
War Horses or Destriers
·
Claims
the sword is more promising in battle than a gun because there is too much to
keep
track of for just one shot with a gun whereas the sword can strike truer from a
man’s arm than relying on the air to direct the blow
·
A well
trained horse can be a huge help in battle distinguishing the enemy and not
falling on its back
·
the importance
of serving their masters riding them
·
Draws a
connection between war horses and lovers
Of
Ancient Customs
·
Notes
how people mock old customs and ways when the next generation will do the same
to them
·
Criticizes
people for basing their actions by authorities rather than making their own judgments
Of
the Vanity of Words
·
Aristo
defines rhetoric as “A science to persuade people,” while Plato and Socrates
see it
as a vehicle for flattery and deception
Of
a Saying of Caesar
·
humans
endless thirst for new commodities
·
Comments
that once people attain something they want something else new
Of
Vain Subtleties
·
stupidity
and wisdom are the same when it comes to sentiment and resolution
with human
accidents
On
Prayer
·
Follows
the Catholic Church on Philosophical standpoint rather than theological
·
By
submitting himself to god feels he submits his judgments writings and thoughts
·
Finds
that prayers should not be casual deserving recognition as gods words done
rigorously not just on special occasions
·
Questions
Catholic followers for turning to prayer on every problem instead of
considering if it worthy of god
·
people
pray forgiveness when they hope to not be punished which he sees as a sin
On
the Length of Life
·
Comments
on the Balance of Life and Death and the definition of a fulfilled life
·
Finds
death from old age as the best way to die finding old age as a source of fulfillment
with the ability to outlive events of one’s life
·
ability
of old age to make one wise and reminisce on life
·
Finds
the real meaning of life as to live happily
·
importance
of the balance of work and play
·
in old
age we must pass down our knowledge and wisdom to the next generation to help
them grow and learn
Book II:
On
the Inconstancy of Our Actions
·
Notes
divisions amongst people hoping for world peace one day with the world being so
full of injustice
·
Claims
it is unfair to judge someone on their past because everyone makes mistakes
·
Character
is defined through actions
On
Drunkenness
·
Misdeeds
are all the same in that they are misdeeds however the severity is what
separates them
·
Montaigne
considers drunkenness a severe sin because it is the worst state of a man to
have no control of himself and causes the release of intimate secrets all of
which reveals our darker side
·
Pleasure
based on drunkenness leads to depression and despair via drunkenness
A Custom
of the Isle of Cea
·
suicide
can be provoked by anything including hope
·
people
can be blinded by religion and unable to connect with common sense
·
we need
to do what is necessary to move forward rather than stay with the bible
Work
Can Wait Till Tomorrow
·
Though
life needs to have work in it, there also needs to be a degree of enjoyment and
pleasure while maintaining income
On
Conscience
·
Both a
gift and curse it can make us evaluate things from different angles often
giving us doubt and guilt
On
Practice
Questions
·
Socrates
view of living life after death rather than living the one you are in as
Montaigne believes
·
our
actions reflect what type of person we are
·
no one
can accuse you of living incorrectly
On
Rewards for Honor
·
Reward
and recognition is important for those that earn it
·
people
can’t overlook the good others have done Injustices in reward such as deserving
people overlooked
·
War
official receiving reward rather than soldier who fought
On
the Affection of Fathers for Their Children
·
arguments
with his mother over financials and inheritance
·
ability
for boys to take over a family and it’s money
·
To love
kids we need to enrich them and help make them better not love them
inappropriately
·
Montaigne
believes you are responsible for the wellbeing of your children even when they
are adults
·
parents
that are in love with their own children is revolting
On
the Armour of the Parthians
·
Though
armor can be a burden it can still be beneficial
·
Describes
French knight’s armor with its flexibility to breathe
On
Books
·
Books
open us to endless knowledge and truth however ignorance can over shadow said
truth
·
Open
mindedness can be one of the best qualities someone can have
·
Montaigne
uses books to learn and grow his being
·
Strives
to understand all passages and unfamiliar sections and master meanings
Illustrates the meaning of learning
·
Finds
Plutarch and Seneca relatable
On
Cruelty
·
Achieving
virtue isn’t easy
To gain anything one must encounter difficulties
It is the
difficulties that teach us virtue
·
Montaigne
suggests that virtues cannot be taught but that we are born with them
·
However
some are acquired over time with experiences
·
animals
feel pain and emotion and states we must be kind to them with respect Arguing
cruelty stretches into animal cruelty
The
Apology of Raymond Sebond
·
Montaigne
explains his father liked education and valued it greatly
·
Objects
that Sebond doesn’t show Christianity having any superiority with other pagan
religions
·
attempts
to support Christianity rationally doesn’t work since it is based on faith
·
The
entire essay argues the weakness of human reason and inability to see the truth
On
Judging Someone Else’s Death
·
Death
is very noteworthy in life but is hard to cope with in the final moment
The
more self important we see ourselves the harder it is to cope and hard to
picture the world without ourselves
Death would be prolonged by Emperors via
torture
Suicides aren’t always followed through and may need to be aided by
someone else It can be considered strange to not fear death
How
Our Mind Tangles Itself Up
·
If
forced to choose between food and drink we would die of both hunger and thirst
That
Difficulty Increases Desire
·
The
struggle to attain things increases the value we have for them
·
one
should overcome things in their way to pursue what we want
·
Beauty
is achieved by facing difficulties
·
People
yearn to do things that are forbidden there is no charm when allowed to do
things
·
People like
being bad
·
Defense
attracts offense open doors protect themselves
·
People
enjoy the challenge
On
Glory
·
Though
glory can be won it isn’t always earned
·
There
is no worth in Glory when no one is looking
·
This is
because someone has to bring back news of your triumph
·
People
are usually more concerned with being known rather than what they are known for
reflecting that people just like attention
·
Only
survivors get glory those who die in war tend to be forgotten
·
Speech
and thought can distinguish the good and bad
On
Presumption
·
People
over estimate their worth with high opinions of themselves
·
Greeting
people without regarding their status takes away meaning
·
Some
people get pleasure from their own writing
·
Notes
men are judged on their height and are treated like a woman if not tall
·
Neither
face nor hair makes him beautiful solely judged on height
·
Being
modest and not giving yourself much worth people can’t but you down any lower
than you have already put yourself
On Giving the Lie
·
Montaigne
is proud to be honest when he sees many people lying to each other’s faces
On
Freedom of Conscience
·
Notes
that the Christian ruler did good things by lowering taxes and therefore
honored his religion
·
When a
king couldn’t accomplish what he wished he pretended to do what he could
On
Thumbs
·
doctors
see the thumb as the master finger
·
in Rome
it is a sign of approval to put a thumb down and is disapproval to stick it up
·
that
Romans didn’t have to serve in the army if their thumb was hurt because they
couldn’t hold a weapon
·
Augustus
took away the property of a man who cut his son thumb off so he wouldn’t have to
serve in the army
·
Cauis
the fifth cut off his left thumb for the same reason and was imprisoned
·
Generarls
cutting thumbs off of defeated armies
On
Cowardice, the Mother of Cruelty
·
the
worst people have womanlike weakness
·
crying
as a weakness
·
Comments
of the loss of courage bravery and honor when there is an open target in battle
·
Expresses
displeasure at gentlemen acting as soldiers
·
cowardice
in killing those that can do harm to you
·
Expresses
displeasure towards torture
There
is a Season for Everything
·
wise
men even set limits for good things
·
Montaigne
enjoys closure in his life not continuing anything for more than a year
starting new and saying goodbye to the old
·
old age
secures his worries about life
·
things
so that when you are ready to die you can leave satisfied with your knowledge
·
Cato
killed himself to stop wondering if anyone is ready to die even while they’re
still learning
On
Virtue
·
we can
do anything
·
With
ideas planted in our minds and someone is determined anything can happen
·
Another
man cut off his penis because he was failing at a relationship
On
a Monster Child
·
no one
wonders where usual things come from but see abnormalities as signs
·
people
see abnormalities as going against nature but nothing can really be “ against
nature”
On
Anger
·
Upset
with beating and scolding children because they are the future of the
state
Notes that anger can make people act out of their nature
·
Claims
punishments out of anger are unfair
Notes that people don’t always take their
own advice
·
the
anger isn’t always visible
·
people
get angry unreasonably and try to rationalize it when they are actually wrong
·
Claims
women only get mad to make men angry
In
defense of Seneca and Plutarch
·
Montaigne
claims Dion the historian has the wrong opinion
·
Plutarch
is a biographer and writer
·
Montaigne
defends Plutarch’s comparison of Romans and Greeks
·
Bodin
states generally that Greeks are favored
·
Montaigne
notes that Bodin isn’t seeing the bigger picture
The
Tale of Spurina
·
There
are two appetites those of the mind and soul and those of the body
·
Speaks
highly of Caesar noting his many lovers, ambitious orator and writer and notes
that most people were on his side
·
good intentions
with actions lacking wisdom
States moderation was a good virtue
Observation
on Julius Caesar’s Methods of Waging War
·
Gave
some reward to men good looking armor built confidence
·
Eloquent
in speech
Liked to win through strategy than sheer might
·
Confident
and bold
·
With
Time he became more deliberate
·
impulsiveness
of some actions
·
Granted
life to captured soldiers but when his soldiers were captured they’d rather
kill themselves
On
Three Good Wives
·
fathers
don’t show love to their sons to be respected and honored
·
Claims
women do the same to their husbands
·
Rich
Woman’s husband sentenced to death family prevented her from suicide
·
When
husband returned he was to kill himself she stabbed herself first showing it
was easy then he killed himself
On
the Most Excellent of Men
·
Montaigne
puts three men above all other men
·
Homer
because he created lasting gods and was Virgil’s teacher with no other poets
comparing, many famous people use Homer ’s works
·
Alexander
the Great had accomplished so much by 33 claiming to have gotten his virtues
from nature admitting he was lucky
On
the Resemblance of Children to Their Fathers
·
how
extraordinary it is that sperm passes both physical and psychological traits
·
Ponders
how he has a kidney stone like his father
·
Criticizes Doctors advice claiming there is
always counter arguments
·
Switches
to saying he is only against
·
Doctors
art not doctors themselves Calls a doctor to see him
Understands the argument
for medicine
·
their
aren’t two identical opinions in the world